Top 10 Overrated Romance Anime That Deserve a Second Look

Romance anime, with its intricate emotions and captivating characters, has been a beloved genre for anime enthusiasts worldwide. However, within this vast realm, certain series often bask in the spotlight, overshadowing hidden gems that, despite their underrated status, offer tales of love that are both compelling and profound. In this extensive exploration, we embark on a journey through 10 romance anime series that critics may deem overrated but possess a charm, emotional depth, and narrative brilliance that render them absolutely worth your time.

1. “Sword Art Online” (2012) Romance anime


“Sword Art Online” is an anime that frequently falls under scrutiny for its action-oriented approach, leading some to overlook the beautiful love story that blossoms within its virtual world. Critics may label it as “overrated,” but it successfully strikes a balance between adrenaline-pumping battles and heartfelt romance.

The story revolves around Kirito and Asuna, two players trapped in a deadly virtual reality game. Their connection starts as a partnership forged by necessity but evolves into a deep and genuine affection. What sets this anime apart is the exploration of love and trust in the context of an unpredictable gaming environment where death carries real consequences. As they face perilous challenges together, their bond strengthens, and their romance unfolds amidst the danger, creating a unique and emotionally charged narrative that goes beyond the typical romance anime tropes.

2. “Ouran High School Host Club” (2006)

“Ouran High School Host Club” is often brushed aside as a reverse harem comedy, but it’s a hidden gem that offers a delightful and heartwarming take on romance. The story centers around Haruhi Fujioka, a scholarship student at the prestigious Ouran Academy. Her life takes an unexpected turn when she stumbles upon the extravagant and charming young men of the Host Club.

Beyond the comedic antics and playful banter, the series delves into Haruhi’s evolving relationships with the host club members, particularly Tamaki Suoh. Their connection gradually deepens as they learn more about each other’s backgrounds, dreams, and vulnerabilities. This anime excels in character development, showcasing how genuine relationships can transcend initial impressions and societal boundaries.

3. “Fruits Basket” (2001 and 2019)

Fruits Basket,” despite its popularity, deserves every ounce of praise it receives. It’s a heartwarming and emotionally resonant story that revolves around Tohru Honda, a compassionate and selfless girl who stumbles upon the enigmatic Sohma family.

The Sohmas bear a peculiar curse that causes them to transform into animals from the Chinese zodiac when hugged by someone of the opposite sex. Tohru’s unconditional acceptance and empathy become a catalyst for healing within the fractured Sohma family. Her relationship with Kyo, Yuki, and other members of the zodiac is a testament to the power of compassion, acceptance, and the capacity for love to heal emotional wounds. “Fruits Basket” is a masterpiece in character development, delivering a profoundly moving and unforgettable exploration of love and family.

4. “Kimi ni Todoke” (2009)

“Kimi ni Todoke” is a delightful departure from typical high school romance anime. The story follows Sawako Kuronuma, a girl often misunderstood due to her eerie resemblance to Sadako from the horror film “The Ring.” Her journey toward friendship and love is at the heart of this series.

Sawako’s gradual transformation from a misunderstood loner to a beloved member of her class is both heartwarming and inspirational. Her budding relationship with Kazehaya Shouta, the popular and charismatic boy in her class, is a beautiful portrayal of young love. The anime emphasizes the importance of genuine connections, effective communication, and breaking down social barriers in a world where misunderstandings often rule. “Kimi ni Todoke” is a touching and sincere exploration of love in its purest form.

5. “Toradora!” (2008)

“Toradora!” is a series often celebrated for its well-crafted characters and intricate relationships. Ryuuji Takasu and Taiga Aisaka, the main characters, initially appear as complete opposites. Ryuuji is a kind-hearted but intimidating-looking boy, while Taiga is a tiny but fierce girl with a fiery temper.

Their unexpected alliance begins as they agree to help each other with their respective crushes. However, as they spend more time together, their feelings evolve in a gradual and authentic manner. The beauty of “Toradora!” lies in its ability to explore the complexities of human emotions, revealing that love can be both a comforting sanctuary and a tumultuous rollercoaster. The character development and emotional depth in this anime make it a standout in the genre.

Also Read: Ranking the 10 Most Formidable Anime Dragons in the World of Fantasy

6. “Golden Time” (2013)

“Golden Time” is a romance anime that dares to delve into the complexities of relationships and memory loss. The story centers around Tada Banri, a law school student who faces the unique challenge of dealing with amnesia.

As Banri navigates law school, he encounters Koko Kaga, an enigmatic and vibrant girl with her own set of personal struggles. Their budding romance unfolds amid the backdrop of self-discovery and the pursuit of dreams. “Golden Time” takes the viewers on a journey that explores the challenges of maintaining a relationship while confronting personal demons, emphasizing the importance of understanding oneself and the person you love.

7. “The Pet Girl of Sakurasou” (2012)

While not as widely recognized as some other titles, “The Pet Girl of Sakurasou” is a hidden gem in the world of romantic comedies. The narrative revolves around Sakurasou Dormitory, a place that houses a group of eccentric and highly talented students, including Mashiro Shiina, a brilliantly gifted artist.

The story brilliantly portrays the dynamics between the dorm’s residents, emphasizing the growth of relationships and the pursuit of dreams. It delves into the challenges faced by talented individuals as they navigate the path to success. Amidst the humor and quirky personalities, the anime beautifully depicts the bonds that form between the characters, leading to unexpected connections and profound personal growth.

8. “Say I Love You” (2012)

“Say I Love You” offers a refreshing take on teenage romance by grounding itself in realism. The story centers around Mei Tachibana, an introverted high school student who has never experienced friendship or romance. Her life takes a significant turn when she crosses paths with Yamato Kurosawa, a popular and outgoing classmate.

Their relationship unfolds naturally, as they learn to trust and rely on each other. “Say I Love You” is a mature exploration of young love, highlighting the importance of self-acceptance, communication, and the genuine connections that can be formed when people break down their emotional barriers. It is a heartfelt portrayal of the transformative power of love in the lives of two seemingly incompatible individuals.

9. “Nisekoi: False Love” (2014)

“Nisekoi” is often criticized for its harem elements and the perception of slow romantic progress. However, this anime excels in humor and suspense, keeping viewers engaged through its comedic moments and intriguing plot.

The story follows Raku Ichijou, the heir to a yakuza family, and his complicated relationships with several girls from rival factions. Amidst the chaos and misunderstandings, the anime keeps audiences guessing about Raku’s true feelings and the identity of the girl he truly loves. “Nisekoi” combines elements of romantic comedy with the intricacies of yakuza life, offering a unique and entertaining narrative that takes unexpected turns.

10. “Plastic Memories” (2015)

“Plastic Memories” ventures into the realm of romance with a sci-fi twist. The anime is set in a world where humans coexist with highly lifelike androids. The central narrative follows Tsukasa Mizugaki, who joins the Terminal Service, a company responsible for retrieving androids at the end of their limited lifespans.

Tsukasa is paired with Isla, an android with limited time remaining. Their journey together explores the intricate dynamics between humans and artificial beings. “Plastic Memories” raises thought-provoking questions about love, mortality, and the boundaries between humanity and technology. The emotional depth of Tsukasa and Isla’s relationship is both poignant and compelling, making it a standout in the romance genre.


These 10 romance anime series may carry the burden of being labeled “overrated,” but beneath the surface, they offer intricate, emotionally charged, and profoundly moving narratives that deserve your attention. Do not let preconceived notions deter you; instead, immerse yourself in the rich character development, heartfelt moments, and authentic connections they provide. In the vast world of anime, hidden treasures often lie just beneath the surface, waiting for discerning viewers to unearth their profound beauty and depth. Give these series a chance, and you may find yourself falling in love with their stories all over again.

3 thoughts on “Top 10 Overrated Romance Anime That Deserve a Second Look”

Comments are closed.